A tough call, but new stadium is needed
Change is such a small word that has such a huge impact on how people live their lives.
Nowhere has that become more evident than when you talk to people in Omaha about the proposed downtown stadium that would replace Rosenblatt Stadium as the home for the College World Series.
Those that are in support of the new stadium talk about keeping the CWS in Omaha for a long time to come and getting a facility built that will be easier to access. Those that are opposed talk about the tradition and that the stadium, even at 60 years of age, still has a lot of life left in it.
It's a tough situation to be in, especially if you're Omaha Mayor Mike Fahey. Nobody wants to be known as the mayor who allowed college athletics' longest-running festival of fun to leave town, yet at the same time he is calling for the abandonment of a time-honored city treasure that college baseball fans know as "The Johnny" or, simply put, "Rosenblatt."
At the news conference Wednesday, stadium committee officials and Fahey spent over 90 minutes talking with the media about the proposal. There are still questions that need to be answered, and you aren't going to get everybody on board with this no matter how hard you try. But the bottom line is that, if Omaha wants to maintain its hold on the College World Series (which will be 60 years when the contract runs out in 2010), a new stadium is the best, and only, option available.
Rosenblatt Stadium has undergone countless renovations during its 60-year run. Cost estimates on properly renovating the facility would run in the $60-70 million range. In addition, the renovation would require much more than simply slapping a few coats of paint on and installing new seats -- the stadium itself would have to be completely reconstructed to create concourse space, and such construction isn't done overnight. In fact, the committee estimated that the CWS would actually have to be played somewhere else for one year, and the Omaha Royals would have to find a temporary home somewhere else for parts of two seasons.
In addition, the city would have to negotiate with homeowners along 13th Street to buy their property so a "clean zone" could be built around a "new" Rosenblatt. And I'm no expert on the neighborhood, but if you think those people are going to willingly sell their property and move, you're completely out of your mind.
Although the projected cost of the new stadium is in the $128 million neighborhood, the funding for the stadium actually makes sense. A little over a third of the funding would come from private sources. Another $20 million or so will come from stadium revenue, naming rights, parking fees, etc. And about $58 million would come from hotel and car rental taxes as well as local keno revenue. For local taxpayers, the fact that they won't see any city property tax increases should be looked at as a good thing.
The NCAA is telling the public that they have had no input on this situation (and if you know how the NCAA works, you know that this is rubbish). But you can bet that the NCAA is keeping a very close eye on what goes on in Omaha with the debate on this construction. The NCAA might -- might -- sign on for another five years if things aren't settled soon and more time is needed. They are more likely, though, to take the College World Series to someplace like the city where their current headquarters is located, Indianapolis (try saying "The Road To Indianapolis" -- it just doesn't sound right).
Ultimately, the building of a new stadium and the abandoning of a stadium that has served the city and all of college baseball well over the past six decades is not an easy one to accept, nor is it easy to put together. What it will lose in charm and tradition it will gain in a fresh look and a guarantee that it won't be moving out of Omaha for 20 years or more.
But if Omaha REALLY wants to keep the College World Series in Omaha, then a new stadium is something they must do, regardless of what the NCAA is saying about the organization not holding anyone's feet to the fire. It's a tough call and it's going to be hard for some in Omaha to accept change, but the bottom line is that a new stadium is the way to go if we want to continue seeing the nation's best college baseball players look to Omaha as their ultimate destination.
(NOTE: To see complete comprehensive details of the plans for a new downtown stadium, check out the Omaha Stadium website.)